While the Nvidia story and Anthropic’s highly anticipated IPO are dominating market headlines this week, bitcoin is also feeling the effects of shifting investor risk appetite. Although bitcoin has gained broader acceptance among retail and institutional investors, its recent pullback highlights the volatility that underlies cryptocurrencies. While spot bitcoin ETFs still dominate the crypto ETF market, issuers have introduced alternative strategies ranging from inverse and tail-risk hedging ETFs to multi-asset bitcoin ETFs, offering investors more ways to navigate volatility based on their risk tolerances and market outlooks.Key Takeaways:
Bitcoin’s recent pullback highlights its sensitivity to broader market risks, like the midterms and broader tech weakness.
Inverse, tail-risk, and rotational ETFs offer alternative ways to navigate bitcoin volatility and manage downside exposure.
Multi-asset bitcoin ETFs provide opportunities beyond traditional spot bitcoin exposure.
Several Headwinds Spark Recent Weakness in BitcoinBitcoin has faced several headwinds in recent weeks. It began with the October 29 hack of Binance, the world’s largest cryptocurrency exchange. The attack resulted in approximately $6.3 billion in stolen digital assets, renewing concerns about security. Although Binance committed to covering customer losses, the incident highlighted the safety risks that remain within the broader crypto world. While spot bitcoin ETFs did not directly lose any bitcoin in the hack, the event resulted in over $600 million in net outflows for the group in a single day.
Bitcoin briefly recovered above $80,000 following the November 3 U.S. midterm elections. However, the rally was short-lived as the Democratic sweep raised uncertainty surrounding the future of crypto-friendly legislation. There are also factors beyond the cryptocurrency industry. Concerns over AI infrastructure spending and recent developments at Nvidia have contributed to a broader sell-off in technology stocks. This has also affected bitcoin prices. Meanwhile, persistent inflation and expectations for additional Federal Reserve rate hikes have weighed on risk assets, including bitcoin.
On November 15, bitcoin briefly fell to approximately $62,000, its lowest level since July, as selling pressures increased. While some crypto-specific developments have contributed to the recent weakness, bitcoin’s performance illustrates how the cryptocurrency remains largely sensitive to broader equity market sentiment and macroeconomic uncertainty.Spot Bitcoin ETFs Face OutflowsAlongside the decline in bitcoin prices, spot bitcoin ETFs have experienced a shift in investor sentiment. Through November 17, U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs saw approximately $2.5 billion in net outflows for the month, with the largest spot bitcoin ETF, the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (IBIT ), accounting for $1.5 billion of those outflows.
Recent outflows suggest that investors are reducing their exposure to bitcoin. However, this may be more reflective of short-term selling than a fundamental shift in long-term views. According to the recent CoinShares Affluent Investor Crypto Report, 40% of U.S. high net worth investors surveyed ranked crypto first for long-term performance expectations over equities, bonds, real estate, and commodities. Since their launch in January 2024, U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs have still accumulated approximately $56.4 billion in net inflows. The accumulation occurred despite several periods of significant volatility.Unlike some of the earlier bitcoin market cycles, however, investors now have a much broader selection of bitcoin ETF strategies to choose from. While spot bitcoin ETFs have struggled from a performance perspective, several alternative strategies have been better positioned to navigate the recent downturn, whether through downside hedging or reduced sensitivity to bitcoin prices.
These strategies are the most direct examples of how investors could potentially benefit from declining bitcoin prices.Profiting From Bitcoin’s Weakness: Inverse and Tail ETFsSome of the strongest-performing bitcoin ETFs during the recent sell-off have logically been inverse ETFs, including the ProShares Short Bitcoin ETF (BITI C+), which seeks to deliver -1x the daily returns of the Bloomberg Bitcoin Index. For investors seeking more aggressive exposure, the ProShares UltraShort Bitcoin ETF (SBIT ) seeks to deliver -2x the daily returns of the same Bloomberg Bitcoin Index. Like other leveraged and inverse ETFs, both BITI and SBIT reset their exposure daily. This means that the effects of compounding can cause returns over longer periods to drift significantly from their stated investment objectives. These ETFs are generally better suited as short-term trading tools, particularly given the potential for sharp reversals in bitcoin prices.
The Nicholas Bitcoin Tail ETF (BHDG), takes advantage of bitcoin weakness through an actively managed options strategy. The ETF purchases put options while selling call options or call spreads to partially offset the cost of downside protection. If bitcoin declines sharply, the long puts rise in value. If bitcoin rises, the long puts will lose value but losses will be capped at the max loss of the call spreads. Unlike traditional inverse ETFs, BHDG does not target a fixed multiple of bitcoin’s daily returns. The strategy could serve as a complementary allocation for long-term bitcoin investors seeking to reduce downside risk.Multi-Asset Bitcoin ETFs Provide Unique Opportunities The Bitwise Trendwise Bitcoin and Treasuries Rotation Strategy ETF (BITC ) manages bitcoin’s downside risk by rotating between 100% exposure to bitcoin futures or 100% exposure to U.S. Treasuries based on market momentum. The ETF uses bitcoin’s 10-day and 20-day exponential moving averages to determine its exposure, shifting into bitcoin futures when momentum is positive and Treasuries when momentum turns negative. While this strategy has outperformed spot bitcoin ETFs year to date, it can introduce some timing risk because bitcoin prices can reverse quickly, potentially leaving the fund in Treasuries during part of a rebound or exposed to bitcoin during part of a downward trend.The Franklin U.S. Equity Bitcoin DRIP Index ETF (FBEQ), which was incepted on October 27, offers a different approach to building bitcoin exposure alongside traditional equities. The ETF tracks the VettaFi U.S. Large-Cap 500 Bitcoin DRIP Index. It initially allocates 95% to large-cap U.S. equities and 5% to bitcoin, reinvesting dividends from the equity portion into bitcoin exposure. This allows investors to gradually accumulate bitcoin exposure over time, while maintaining a position primarily driven by traditional equities within a single ETF. As of November 17, FBEQ holds a 3.4% weight to bitcoin through the Franklin Bitcoin ETF (EZBC ).
The Franklin U.S. Innovation Bitcoin DRIP Index ETF (FIBT) was launched at the same time as FBEQ and follows a similar strategy focusing on 100 large Nasdaq-listed nonfinancial companies, providing greater exposure to technology and growth-oriented stocks. As of November 17, FIBT holds a 2.8% weight to bitcoin through EZBC. Both FBEQ and FIBT’s indexes cap overall bitcoin exposure at 20%, while applying a 5% cap at each quarterly rebalance. These strategies may appeal to investors who remain bullish on bitcoin’s long-term prospects but prefer a smaller allocation within an equity portfolio.Upcoming Webcast: How Bitcoin Complements Equity ExposuresOn Friday, November 20 at 2 PM ET, I will be moderating an educational webcast with Franklin Templeton’s Todd Mathias (head of US ETF product strategy) and Alison Holland (ETF product specialist). Todd and Alison will provide an overview of how Bitcoin can complement equity exposures and differentiate portfolio returns. Register here to join us for the discussion.Bottom Line:The continued expansion of the bitcoin ETF market has given investors more than just easier access to the cryptocurrency, offering greater flexibility in how they incorporate bitcoin-related exposure into their portfolios. As bitcoin continues to experience periods of volatility, understanding the differences between these strategies can help investors select the exposure that best aligns with their broader portfolio goals.
For more news, information, and analysis, visit the Thematic Investing Content Hub.
VettaFi LLC (“VettaFi”) is the index administrator and calculation agent for FBEQ and FIBT, for which it receives a fee. However, FBEQ and FIBT are not issued, sponsored, endorsed, or sold by VettaFi, and VettaFi has no obligation or liability in connection with the issuance, administration, marketing, or trading of FBEQ and FIBT.